← Analysis
The happiest place the count stopped counting
A companion to this site's piece on the 11-times income gap between Loudoun County, Virginia and Las Marías, Puerto Rico: income was never the whole story, and Puerto Rico is the proof. In 2016, the UN-backed World Happiness Report ranked Puerto Rico 15th happiest in the world out of 157 places measured -- ahead of the United States itself that year. By the very next year's report, Puerto Rico had vanished from the rankings entirely, and it has not reappeared since. Not a decline. A removal.

This site's own data recently traced an 11-times income gap between Loudoun County, Virginia, the richest county in the country, and Las Marías, Puerto Rico, the poorest.[1] Income was never going to be the whole story, and Puerto Rico turns out to be the clearest possible proof of why.

In 2016, the United Nations-backed World Happiness Report — built from Gallup World Poll interviews asking people to rate their own lives on a 0-to-10 ladder, weighted by income, social support, life expectancy, freedom, generosity, and trust — ranked Puerto Rico 15th happiest out of 157 countries and territories measured. That year, Puerto Rico ranked ahead of the United States itself.[2] The poorest place in the entire U.S. federal income count was, by the world's own most-cited self-reported wellbeing measure, one of the most content populations on Earth.

By the very next year's report, Puerto Rico was gone from the list. Not lower. Absent — dropped from the statistical appendix entirely, with no ranking published in its place.[3] It has not reappeared in the ten years since.[4]

This is the same shape this site already found in Puerto Rico's absence from the federal crime dataset, now showing up in a completely different, independently run measurement built by a completely different institution. Not a place doing badly on every count. A place doing well by at least one real count, then removed from being counted at all — income last, crime data zero, and now a happiness ranking that peaked ahead of the mainland it is legally, permanently part of, then simply stopped being asked. A third piece asks the question that actually matters: not why the count stopped, but what produced the result in the first place.

The takeaway A companion finding to this site's 11-times income-gap piece on Loudoun County, VA and Las Marías, Puerto Rico: income was never the whole story. In 2016, the UN-backed World Happiness Report ranked Puerto Rico 15th happiest in the world out of 157 places -- ahead of the United States that year. By 2017's report, Puerto Rico had vanished from the rankings entirely and has not reappeared since. Not a falling score. A removal from the count. The same place this site found earning 11 times less than the richest U.S. county, and absent from the federal crime dataset, once ranked among the happiest places on Earth by its own residents' account -- then stopped being measured at all.
Sources
  1. Oluwadi, Same country, same currency, eleven times the income
  2. Caribbean Business, Puerto Rico Among the Happiest Countries in the World
  3. World Happiness Report, Statistical Appendix for "The Social Foundations of World Happiness" (2017)
  4. FloriCua News, US and Puerto Rico were not included in the world's happiest countries list